So, give me Favre, Starr, Rodgers, Herber and Dickey, and we have a better argument. Otherwise, I think the Colts, Cowboys and 49ers are head-and-shoulders above everyone else on this list. Sure, I would take the Packers’ Top 3 over just about anyone else’s, but Danny White, Don Meredith, YA Title and Earl Morrell are in a different league than Dickey and Majkowski. Again, give me Herber and it is a closer argument.

Frankly, the Steelers, Vikings, Saints and Raiders have no business being on this list. If the horse shit Kordell Stewart is among your top 5 QBs, then enough said.

The guy was phenomenal. He played with a chain tied to his left wrist so that he could not raise that arm more that shoulder height. He had some kind of chronic, banged up left-side shoulder problem that raising his arm too high would exacerbatek, dangerously.

Luckily, for the Packers, he was right handed.

His battles with Sid Luckman of the Bears were classic.

Majkowski was actually not that bad and Lynn Dickey was far better than the teams he played on. Put him on a competitive team and he could have been a regular pro-bowl player.

Also forgotten is Tobin Rote, who had some great seasons on the awful Packer teams of the 50′s.